Blond(e)s or Redheads?

Comments are expressly solicited.

In the course of going about living his life, a man notices that he has a dispro­por­tionate pref­erence for redheads as romantic interests. Not being a lazy man, he engages in some lengthy intro­spection and arrives at the following accurate conclusions:

  1. His pref­erence for redheads makes him more likely to inves­tigate the possi­bility of romance with redheads than with non-​​redheads.
  2. Red hair is not a factor bearing any weight on his decision to engage in, continue, or end a romance.
  3. His romances with redheads are no more or less healthy and rational than his romances with non-​​redheads.
  4. He honestly does not know why he prefers redheads.
  5. He can find no reason why he ought to prefer redheads, nor any reason why he out not to prefer them.

In other words, for some reason, he likes redheads, and acting in accord with the pref­erence does him no harm. Nor does it help him much, except that he derives marginally more pleasure (again, for an unknown reason) from his rela­tion­ships with redheads.

Does he have any moral oblig­ation to continue to inves­tigate the psycho-​​epistemological roots of his pref­erence for redheads? To refrain from acting on the pref­erence until such time as its roots are discovered?

What are your thoughts? I have my own answer, which I will post later.

  • Trackback are closed
  • Comments (1)
    • James
    • May 7th, 2008 1:04am

    If he has reason to suspect that an answer will never be known, he should inves­tigate it no further. He should also not worry about obser­vation #1, since either outcome is good: he will engage in a non-​​red-​​haired romance where the missing marginal pleasure derived from the red hair is not noticed, or he will engage in a red-​​head romance where the marginal pleasure is noticed. He should defi­nitely not refrain from acting on the marginal pleasure.

    In order, I prefer straw­berry red-​​heads, red-​​heads, blondes, the black-​​haired, and the brown-​​haired. I doubt I will ever know why, and it doesn’t bother me. But in context, the rest usually outweighs the hair color anyway. There are so many beautiful people “styles.”

Comment are closed.